We have completed a comprehensive status review under the ESA for the orange clownfish and we determined that, based on the best scientific and commercial data available, the orange clownfish does not warrant listing under the ESA. We conclude that the orange clownfish is not currently in danger of extinction throughout all or a significant portion of its range and is not likely to become so within the foreseeable future.
Along with the orange clownfish, CBD petitioned NMFS to list these seven other damselfish species under the ESA:
- Yellowtail Damselfish (Microspathodon chrysurus)
- Hawaiian Dascyllus (Dascyllus albisella)
- Blue-eyed Damselfish (Plectroglyphidodon johnstonianus)
- Black-axil Chromis (Chromis atripectoralis)
- Blue-green Damselfish (Chromis viridis)
- Reticulated Damselfish (Dascyllus reticulatus)
- Blackbar Devil (Plectroglyphidodon dickii)
NMFS Response to the Petition
The NMFS Pacific Islands Regional Office (PIRO) undertook the response to the petition to list the seven Indo-Pacific species of damselfishes, while the Southeast Regional Office (SERO) undertook the response to the yellowtail damselfish, the only species not native to the Indo-Pacific. Last September, NMFS published a positive 90-day finding for the orange clownfish and a negative 90-day finding for the six other Indo-Pacific damselfishes. This past February, NMFS announced a negative 90-day finding for the the yellowtail damselfish.
A positive 90-day finding (I covered the orange clownfish positive 90-day finding for CORAL Magazine) indicates that NMFS finds that a petition itself presents “substantial scientific or commercial information indicating the petitioned action of listing may be warranted.” In the words of an NMFS source, a positive 90-day finding is “a very low bar.” Any positive 90-day finding results in a status review, during which NMFS conducts extensive research into the species. A 12-month finding, such as the one published today in the Federal Register for the orange clownfish, is the end result of the status review.
Comprehensive Status Review
In the course of the status review, NMFS looked specifically at 12 identified threats to the orange clownfish including destruction, modification or curtailment of the species’ habitat or range; over-utilization for commercial, recreational, scientific or educational purposes; disease and predation; inadequacy of existing regulatory mechanisms; and other natural or manmade factors affecting the species existence. When reporting on NMFS’s decision to undertake a status review for the orange clownfish, many popular media outlets focused almost exclusively on the affects of the marine aquarium trade on the species. Some claimed that overfishing and destructive fishing for the aquarium trade were threatening the species. A few outlets published data that was either out-of-date, misleading or flatly incorrect showing that the aquarium trade was potentially over-harvesting the species.
While the marine aquarium trade, and specifically marine aquarium fisheries in source countries throughout the orange clownfish’s range, are data-poor, NMFS determined the threat of collection for the aquarium trade “has a low likelihood of having a significant effect on the species’ risk of extinction now or in the foreseeable future.”
While NMFS found that “[c]lownfish, specifically A. ocellaris and A. percula, are among the top five most imported and exported species of marine aquarium fish in the aquarium trade,” NMFS points out that many of the imported specimens are actually aquacultured fishes. According to the data collected during the course of the status review, NMFS determined that 80 percent of A. percula imports to the United States originated in the Philippines and Indonesia. The status review points out, however, that “these countries are outside the geographic range of A. percula, indicating that 80 percent or more of the imported individuals were likely propagated in captivity and not collected from the wild, or misidentified.”
Total Aquarium Harvest Less than 0.0076 Percent of Wild Population
“If we extrapolate the U.S. import estimate [50-70 percent of aquarium reef fish in the global trade] to infer global wild harvest for the aquarium trade,” NMFS writes in the status review, “the number of globally traded wild A. percula in 2011 was likely closer to approximately 70,000-100,000 individuals, with as much as 80 percent potentially originating from aquaculture operations and not actually harvested from the wild (or misidentified if U.S. imports are considered representative of the global trade).” Based on their research, NMFS conservatively assumes 100,000 orange clownfish are harvested from the wild annually, saying this number is likely “a vast over-estimate.” Based on these estimates, fishing for the aquarium trade, according to the status review, probably represents far less than 0.0076 percent of the wild global population size of 13-18 million individual A. percula. As such, NMFS concludes:
Considering the estimated proportion of the population harvested annually, the principles of fisheries management and population growth, the ease and popularity of captive propagation of the species, and the apparent consumer preference for captively-reared fish for home aquaria, we have determined that overutilization due to collection for the aquarium trade has a low likelihood of contributing significantly to the extinction risk of the orange clownfish now or in the foreseeable future.